Loading…
Faithlife Study Bible
Restore columns
Exit Fullscreen

2:1 with partiality James advises the church not to show partiality in their interactions with others; the implication is that the church was already engaged in this practice.

2:2 someone enters into your assembly Illustrates partiality shown within a community. Apparently the recipients of this letter had shown favoritism to a visitor or member of high social standing.

2:4 distinctions among yourselves The ot prohibits people from discriminating between the rich and the poor (Lev 19:15); the practice also goes against God’s character (Deut 10:17; Job 34:19).

James may be addressing any expression of discrimination, whether based on race, socio-economic status, education, or gender.

become judges with evil thoughts The church may have been passing judgment based on evil motives, or using unacceptable standards in judging.

2:5 poor of the world James does not mean that the rich are at a disadvantage when it comes to believing, but that the poor are more apt to rely on God and subsequently come to faith because of their immediate physical needs. People without physical needs only feel spiritual needs (and at times the things they think are needs but are actually desires), whereas people with physical needs feel them and spiritual needs.

In first-century Israel, society was divided between a small, wealthy class and a large, poor class of peasants or artisans. Jesus expressed a special interest in the impoverished throughout His ministry (Matt 11:5; Luke 4:18). Also, in the ot, God gave many of His promises specifically to the poor (1 Sam 2:8; Psa 140:12; Isa 11:4).

to be rich in faith James indicates that the poor are wealthy in terms of their salvation and its associated blessings, not in terms of material goods. From God’s perspective, the impoverished are destined to possess the spiritual wealth that accompanies faith.

the kingdom Refers to the full rule of God—a state of blessing in which God’s will and reign are absolutely established. Being an heir of the kingdom means possessing eternal life (Mark 10:17–23; Luke 18:29–30) and salvation (Luke 18:18–26). See Matt 3:2 and note, as well as Matt 4:17 and note.

The Kingdom of God: Already but Not Yet

2:6 you have dishonored the poor Even though God chose the poor, the church has treated them with disrespect. See note on Jas 2:2.

dragging you into the courts The wealthy apparently were applying legal pressure to the poor, perhaps regarding wages, rent, and other forms of debt.

2:7 blaspheme the good name James accuses the wealthy of insulting or slandering the name of Christ. See note on v. 6.

2:8 royal law James may use this term because he associates the law with the kingdom of God. See note on 1:25.

You shall love your neighbor as yourself James quotes Lev 19:18. Jesus cites this in Matt 22:39 as the second-greatest commandment (see Matt 7:12 and note).

2:9 if you show partiality, you commit sin Contrasts obedience to the royal law (see note on Jas 2:8); showing partiality is opposed to loving one’s neighbor—it is an act of sin.

convicted by the law James personifies the law as a judge pronouncing a guilty verdict on the accused for breaking it. It is unclear whether James refers here to the royal law or the ot law, but based on his next phrase—and it being steeped in a Jewish context—it seems that he is referring to the ot law.

2:10 has become guilty of all Reflects the belief that the ot law was to be kept in its entirety (Gal 5:3).

2:11 the one who Refers to God, who spoke these commands (Exod 20:13–14).

2:12 by the law of liberty See note on Jas 1:25.

2:13 the one who has not practiced mercy Failure to show mercy means a failure to understand God’s mercy (Matt 6:14–15; Gal 6:7).

James might be drawing on ideas from Zech 7:9–10, where mercy is closely related to concern for the poor.

2:14 faith is not able to save him James asserts that genuine faith affects the believer’s behavior; faith that does not affect behavior is superficial and cannot save.

2:17 if it does not have works A living faith is expressed by deeds of Christian love (see note on James 2:8), such as looking after widows and orphans in their distress (1:27).

2:18 someone will say James now introduces a third person into the discussion to defend his position (for rhetorical purposes).

James’ rhetorical opponent may have been proposing two hypothetical individuals (“you” and “I”): one who primarily had faith, another who primarily had works. If so, the opponent may have been arguing for toleration of both individuals. Or, the opponent may have thought that faith does not require any works—asserting that once someone has placed faith in God (which is sufficient for salvation) there is no longer a need to do anything good. James disagrees: works are a natural result of placing faith in God.

faith apart from your works James implies that faith cannot be demonstrated apart from action.

2:19 You believe that God is one James continues to respond to the rhetorical opponent introduced in v. 18 (Deut 6:4; Mark 12:29; Rom 3:30).

James may be referencing monotheism or Yahwism (belief in the superiority of Israel’s God, Yahweh) here, but it seems more likely that his goal is to establish that God cannot disagree with Himself. Thus, it’s impossible to argue that God once wanted people to do good works and now wants them to do nothing. Instead, salvation is a gift—resulting in people no longer having to live by ot laws—and the natural output of believing in that salvation is doing good works, which is in line with God’s ways. He is “one” in His mindset.

Even the demons believe, and shudder Demons expressed belief in the divine (Mark 1:24; 5:7; Acts 16:16–17). They also demonstrated fear before Christ (Mark 1:23, 24; 5:7). Here, James emphasizes that acceptance of a creed is not enough to save a person.

2:20 foolish person The Greek term used here, kenos, refers to intellectual deficiency. In this context, it indicates a person who lacks understanding of spiritual truth.

2:21 our father See note on James 1:1.

offered up his son Isaac on the altar James uses the example of Abraham, who proved his faith through deeds. Abraham didn’t actually sacrifice Isaac, but he bound and placed him on an altar in obedience to God’s command. Thus, God found him faithful through his actions. See Gen 22:1–19.

2:22 faith was working together Works are the result of faith, or at least they should be.

2:23 credited to him for righteousness This phrase implies that the cooperation of Abraham’s faith and deeds was acceptable in God’s sight.

God’s friend See Isa 41:8.

2:24 justified Here, the Greek term dikaioō means “to vindicate” or “to prove or demonstrate something to be true or just” (see Jas 2:21).

Paul’s use of dikaioō in Rom 4 and Gal 2–3 has a different connotation (see note on Rom 4:2). There, he uses the term to speak of God’s declaration of righteousness or innocence that a sinner achieves only through faith. The context there is being in front of God as judge, whereas the context here is how other people judge.

by works and not by faith alone James is not saying that people must perform works in order for God to accept them. Rather, he is asserting that an individual’s true conversion will be justified by deeds of Christian love; deeds are the proof of conversion to other people, and they are the natural result of being faithful to God. Deeds demonstrate the validity of a person’s profession of faith.

In the context of Romans and Galatians, “works” (erga) means being obedient to the Jewish law (Rom 3:20, 28; Gal 2:16; 3:10–12). In the context of James, erga refers to showing one’s faith through doing good deeds. Paul fights the idea that works are the way to be saved, arguing that no one can be saved by works, because all fall short. James is addressing the opposite problem: faith is being used as an excuse not to do any works (not to care for those on the underside of power). Paul also mentions this same problem, agreeing with James that salvation does not mean that Christians stop acting according to God’s standards and doing good by others (Rom 6:15–23). The ot law is not the way Christians come to salvation—salvation comes through belief in God’s faithfulness shown through Christ’s death and resurrection—but it does help Christians understand how to best treat other people.

Biblical Theology

2:25 was not Rahab the prostitute James uses the example of Rahab to further support his claim regarding the unity of faith and deeds. See Josh 2:1–21 and Heb 11:31 and note.

FSB

About Faithlife Study Bible

Faithlife Study Bible (FSB) is your guide to the ancient world of the Old and New Testaments, with study notes and articles that draw from a wide range of academic research. FSB helps you learn how to think about interpretation methods and issues so that you can gain a deeper understanding of the text.

Copyright

Copyright 2012 Logos Bible Software.

Support Info

fsb

Table of Contents