Logos Bible Study

Jeremiah 46:15

The NET BibleOther versions

English

Arabic

Czech

French

German

Hebrew

Hungarian

Italian

Korean

Latin

Portuguese

Russian

Simplified Chinese

Spanish

Traditional Chinese

46:15Why will your soldiers27 be defeated?28

They will not stand because I, the Lord, will thrust29 them down.

Read in Logos

Footnotes

  1. 27 The word translated “soldiers” (אַבִּירִים, ’abbirim) is not the Hebrew word that has been used of soldiers elsewhere in these oracles (גִּבּוֹרִים, gibborim). It is an adjective used as a noun that can apply to animals, i.e., of a bull (Ps 50:13) or a stallion (Judg 5:22). Moreover, the form is masculine plural and the verbs are singular. Hence, many modern commentaries and English versions follow the redivision of the first line presupposed by the Greek version, “Apis has fled” (נָס חַף, nas khaf) and see this as a reference to the bull god of Memphis. However, the noun is used of soldiers in Lam 1:15 and the plural could be the distributive plural, i.e., each and every one (cf. §145.l and compare usage in Gen 27:29).
  2. 28 The Hebrew word used here only occurs here (in the Niphal) and in Prov 28:3 (in the Qal) where it refers to a rain that beats down grain. That idea would fit nicely with the idea of the soldiers being beaten down, or defeated. It is possible that the rarity of this verb (versus the common verb נוּס, nus, “flee”) and the ready identification of Apis with the bull calf (אַבִּיר, ’abbir) has led to the reading of the Greek text (so C. von Orelli, Jeremiah, 327). The verbs in this verse and the following are in the perfect tense but should be understood as prophetic perfects since the text is dealing with what will happen when Nebuchadnezzar comes into Egypt. The text of vv. 18–24 shows a greater mixture with some perfects and some imperfects, sometimes even within the same verse (e.g., v. 22).
  3. 29 Heb “the Lord will thrust them down.” However, the Lord is speaking (cf. clearly in v. 18), so the first person is adopted for the sake of consistency. This has been a consistent problem in the book of Jeremiah where the prophet is so identified with the word of the Lord that he sometimes uses the first person and sometimes the third. It creates confusion for the average reader who is trying to follow the flow of the argument and has been shifted to the first person like this on a number of occasions. and have generally adopted the same policy as have some other modern English versions at various points.

In other versions

ESVEnglish Standard Version

Why are your mighty ones face down?

They do not stand

because the Lord thrust them down.

NIVNew International Version (2011)

Why will your warriors be laid low?

They cannot stand, for the Lord will push them down.

CSBChristian Standard Bible

Why have your strong ones been swept away?

Each has not stood,

for the Lord has thrust him down.

NLTNew Living Translation

Why have your warriors fallen?

They cannot stand, for the Lord has knocked them down.

LEBThe Lexham English Bible

Why are your bulls defeated?

He did not stand because Yahweh thrust him down.

KJV 1900King James Version

Why are thy valiant men swept away?

They stood not, because the Lord did drive them.