in producing strong faith in the unbeliever: “He sometimes even appears to speak of them rather as if they lay side by side with the testimony of the Spirit than acted [as Warfield taught] along with it as co-factors” to convince people of the truth of the Bible.19 Yet after an involved argument Warfield concluded that Calvin meant to say, as Warfield himself did, that the Holy Spirit always exercises his convicting power through the indicia. Of these rejoinders to the objections to his view of