Loading…
Faithlife Study Bible
Restore columns
Exit Fullscreen

5:1 Guard People should approach God’s presence carefully and with humility.

to offer a sacrifice of fools Refers to sacrifices or any other outward expression of religion done without obedience (1 Sam 15:22; Prov 21:27; Isa 1:11–20).

God’s preference for obedience over sacrifice appears throughout the ot (Prov 21:3; Jer 7:22–23). The prophets stress God’s concern with justice and mercy over outward religious expressions (Mic 6:6–8; Hos 6:6). Saul was rejected as king because he did not obey God’s instruction to completely destroy the Amalekites, instead choosing to save some of their animals for sacrifice (1 Sam 15:21–23). Jesus emphasizes this theme in the Gospels (Matt 9:13; 23:23; Mark 12:29–34).

5:2 God is in heaven, and you are on earth God’s dwelling in heaven often appears in the ot (1 Kgs 8:27–30; Psa 115:16). Instead of asserting divine indifference, this image serves to contrast God’s authority with human limitations.

Still, the ot sometimes presents God as distant from His people. Job, for example, believed that God was indifferent to his sufferings (Job 23:8). Throughout most of the book, God does not answer Job’s cries for vindication (Job 30:20), leaving Job feeling as if God were hiding from him (Job 13:23). God eventually responds to Job and emphasizes the vast difference between His power and the “wisdom” of Job and his friends (see note on Job 38:1–41:34).

5:3 the voice of a fool Restraint in speech is a common theme in Wisdom literature. The trouble caused by a fool’s words (Prov 18:6–7) would be avoided by keeping quiet (Prov 21:23); silence makes even a fool seem wise (Prov 17:28). See note on Eccles 3:7.

5:4 do not delay in fulfilling it Leaving a vow unfulfilled was a serious offense. See Num 30:2; Prov 20:25, and Deut 23:21–23, each of which closely resemble this passage.

Vows, when made in situations of distress, often included a promise to return something to God (Gen 28:20–22). For example, Hannah vowed to dedicate her child to God if He would give her a son (1 Sam 1:11–28). Jephthah rashly vowed to sacrifice whatever greeted him at his door (Judg 11:30–40).

Vow BEB

Vow ISBE

5:6 it was a mistake The Hebrew word used here, shegagah, refers to an unintentional or inadvertent sin (see Lev 4:2 and note). The Law had specific instruction for atoning for these types of sins (Lev 4:27–31). Here, the sinner’s claim that it was a “mistake” seems to be dishonest.

5:7 fear God The author advises a reverent fear of God as a guard against presumption. See Eccles 3:14 and note.

5:8 violence or do not see justice and righteousness The author laments the lack of justice (mishpat) and righteousness (tsedeq). The prevalence of injustice has been noted in 3:16 and 4:1. Unfairness, oppression, and injustice constitute a large part of what makes life senseless (see note on 1:2).

This description of injustice contributes to debates about whether Solomon wrote Ecclesiastes. The idea is that, as king, Solomon would have had power to do something about oppression of the poor and other injustices, whereas the author does not appear to be in such a position. See note on 1:1.

5:9 the king profits from the field Wisdom literature often speaks of the value of a wise or competent ruler. See note on 10:16.

5:10 is not satisfied with money Wealth does not satisfy—a discovery already made by the author (2:1–11).

5:11 those who consume it increase Highlights the inability to reach any meaningful gains. Material wealth does not satisfy because consumption or appetite increases as much as goods increase.

5:12 does not allow him to rest The desire for wealth is portrayed as a worrying and unsatisfying quest (2:23; 4:4, 8; 5:17; 6:7). Because death ultimately cancels out all gains, working to accumulate wealth is senseless and a futile “striving after wind.” Compare 2:17 and note.

5:13–14 In this passage, the author describes someone who loses his wealth due to a bad investment and dies with nothing—a senseless and evil (or bad) scenario. Ecclesiastes presents several similar situations in which labor fails to satisfy: 4:4 depicts working from jealousy as senseless and futile; 4:7–8 presents working alone without the ability to share one’s wealth as unsatisfying; 2:18–23 laments leaving the efforts of labor to someone who did not earn them.

5:14 was lost in a bad venture Not only does the accumulation of wealth fail to satisfy, wealth can also be quickly lost.

5:15 naked, he will depart just as he came Similar to the statement Job makes after losing his wealth and children (Job 1:21). The idea is that you can’t take wealth with you when you die.

he will take nothing with him for his toil The senselessness of leaving one’s wealth to someone who has not earned it (Eccles 2:18–21) and accumulating wealth without having someone to share it with (4:7–8) has already been discussed. In this situation, the loss of wealth leaves the owner with nothing.

5:16 What profit The inability to achieve real gain is emphasized throughout the book. The difficulty of producing a profit through hard work especially troubles the author. See note on 1:3.

all his toil for the wind Equivalent to striving after wind (1:14, 17), which describes a senseless or futile activity. Here, the entire efforts of a person’s life are shown to be futile and senseless. See note on 2:17.

5:17 he is frustrated in much sickness and resentment A direct contrast with the person of the following verses who has the ability to enjoy his wealth.

5:18 enjoy all the fruit of the toil Since striving after wealth does not provide any ultimate contentment, people should learn to enjoy their work. See note on 9:7–10.

Work TBD

this is his lot See note on 3:22.

5:19 he also empowers him to enjoy them God does not simply give away wealth and possessions; instead, He gives the ability to enjoy them and be satisfied. Wealth alone is not fulfilling (vv. 10–12; 4:7–8; 6:2, 7).

accept his lot, and to rejoice in the fruit of his toil The ability to accept and enjoy what God gives is a recurring theme in Ecclesiastes. Since their lives are in God’s hand (9:1) and human wisdom is limited (8:16–17), people should be satisfied with God’s provision—whether good or bad (7:14).

5:20 he does not remember the brief days of The content person enjoys life without being preoccupied with accumulating wealth or possessions (vv. 12, 17; 4:6–8).

FSB

About Faithlife Study Bible

Faithlife Study Bible (FSB) is your guide to the ancient world of the Old and New Testaments, with study notes and articles that draw from a wide range of academic research. FSB helps you learn how to think about interpretation methods and issues so that you can gain a deeper understanding of the text.

Copyright

Copyright 2012 Logos Bible Software.

Support Info

fsb

Table of Contents