atheists continue to put forward the same old Euthyphro dilemma. In the recent Cambridge Companion to Atheism (2007), for example, the article on God and morality, written by a prominent ethicist, refers neither to the work of these scholars nor to the solution explained here, but attacks only the view that God arbitrarily made up moral values—a straw man that virtually nobody defends! The mention of Plato brings to mind another possible atheistic response to premise 1.