Logos Bible Study

Job 10:8–10

The NET BibleOther versions

English

Arabic

Czech

French

German

Hebrew

Hungarian

Italian

Korean

Latin

Portuguese

Russian

Simplified Chinese

Spanish

Traditional Chinese

Contradictions in God’s Dealings

10:8“Your hands have shaped20 me and made me,

but21 now you destroy me completely.22

10:9Remember that you have made me as with23 the clay;

will24 you return me to dust?

10:10Did you not pour25 me out like milk,

and curdle26 me like cheese?27

Read in Logos

Footnotes

  1. 20 The root עָצַב (’atsav) is linked by some to an Arabic word meaning “to cut out, hew.” The derived word עֲצַבִּים (’atsabbim) means “idols.” Whatever the precise meaning, the idea is that God formed or gave shape to mankind in creation.
  2. 21 The verb in this part is a preterite with the vav (ו) consecutive. However, here it has merely an external connection with the preceding perfects, so that in reality it presents an antithesis (see §111.e).
  3. 22 Heb “together round about and you destroy me.” The second half of this verse is very difficult. Most commentators follow the and connect the first two words with the second colon as the accents indicate (, “then destroyed every part of me”), rather than with the first colon (“and made me complete,” J. E. Hartley, Job [], ). Instead of “together” some read “after.” Others see in סָבִיב (saviv) not so much an adjectival use but a verbal or adverbial use: “you turn and destroy” or “you destroy utterly (all around).” This makes more sense than “turn.” In addition, the verb form in the line is the preterite with vav consecutive; this may be another example of the transposition of the copula (see 4:6). For yet another option (“You have engulfed me about altogether”), see R. Fuller, “Exodus 21:22: The Miscarriage Interpretation and the Personhood of the Fetus,” 37 (1994): .
  4. 23 The preposition “like” creates a small tension here. So some ignore the preposition and read “clay” as an adverbial accusative of the material ( §117.hh but cf. §119.i with reference to beth essentiae: “as it were, by clay”). The gets around the problem with a different meaning for the verb: “you molded me like clay.” Some suggest the meaning was “as [with] clay” (in the same manner that we have “as [in] the day of Midian” [Isa 9:4]).
  5. 24 The text has a conjunction: “and to dust.…”
  6. 25 The verb נָתַךְ (natakh) means “to flow,” and in the Hiphil, “to cause to flow.”
  7. 26 This verb קָפָא (qafa’) means “to coagulate.” In the Hiphil it means “to stiffen; to congeal.”
  8. 27 The verbs in v. 10 are prefixed conjugations; since the reference is to the womb, these would need to be classified as preterites. These verses figuratively describe the formation of the embryo in the womb.

In other versions

ESVEnglish Standard Version

Your hands fashioned and made me,

and now you have destroyed me altogether.

Remember that you have made me like clay;

and will you return me to the dust?

Did you not pour me out like milk

and curdle me like cheese?

NIVNew International Version (2011)

“Your hands shaped me and made me.

Will you now turn and destroy me?

Remember that you molded me like clay.

Will you now turn me to dust again?

Did you not pour me out like milk

and curdle me like cheese,

CSBChristian Standard Bible

“Your hands shaped me and formed me.

Will you now turn and destroy me?

Please remember that you formed me like clay.

Will you now return me to dust?

Did you not pour me out like milk

and curdle me like cheese?

NLTNew Living Translation

“ ‘You formed me with your hands; you made me,

yet now you completely destroy me.

Remember that you made me from dust—

will you turn me back to dust so soon?

You guided my conception

and formed me in the womb.

LEBThe Lexham English Bible

Your hands fashioned me and made me altogether,

then you destroyed me.

Please remember that you made me like clay,

but you turn me into dust again?

Did you not pour me out like milk

and curdle me like cheese?

KJV 1900King James Version

Thine hands have made me and fashioned me

Together round about; yet thou dost destroy me.

Remember, I beseech thee, that thou hast made me as the clay;

And wilt thou bring me into dust again?

Hast thou not poured me out as milk,

And curdled me like cheese?